In the Chimney With Love by Gary R. Hoffman
by Barb Goffman
From the anthology By the Chimney With Care (Wolfmont Publishing, 2006).
A thief has stolen some of the Christmas presents. All the expensive high-tech ones were left behind, fully wrapped. The police and family are stumped at how the thief knew which presents were which. And why the low-tech ones were the only ones stolen.